[Agenda] [Characteristics] [Architecture] [Results] [Conclusion] [Resources]
[Index] Interoperability tests: results [previous slide] [next slide]
OpenBSD 2.6 (current source tree) KAME (8th stable release) Linux FreeS/WAN 1.1 Pipsecd Check Point VPN-1 (4.0 & 4.1) RedCreek's Ravlin Cisco IOS 12.0
OpenBSD 2.6 (current source tree)
 N/A
Yes (Manual and IKE)
Yes (Manual and IKE)
Yes (Manual only)
Yes (Manual only)
-
Yes (Manual and IKE)
KAME (8th stable release)
Yes (Manual and IKE)
 N/A
-
Yes (Manual only)
Yes (Manual, IKE not tested)
No (need more tests)
Yes (Manual, IKE not tested)
Linux FreeS/WAN 1.1
Yes (IKE and Manual)
Yes (IKE and Manual)
 N/A
-
No (need more tests)
-
Yes (Manual and IKE)
Pipsecd
Yes (Manual only)
 Yes (Manual only) - N/A - - Yes (Manual only)
Check Point VPN-1 (4.0 & 4.1) Yes (Manual only) Yes (Manual, IKE not tested) No (need more tests) Yes (Manual only) N/A Yes (Manual and IKE) No (need more tests)
RedCreek's Ravlin - No (need more tests) - - Yes (Manual and IKE) N/A -
Cisco IOS 12.0 Yes (Manual and IKE) Yes (Manual, IKE not tested)  Yes (Manual and IKE) Yes (Manual only) No (need more tests) - N/A

The dash "-" means that this situation was not tested due to a lack of time or of available test machines.
"No" means that we couldn't get the two implementations to interoperate with reasonable efforts. *********************************************************************
HSC ® © Hervé Schauer Consultants October 1999 - 142, rue de Rivoli - F-75001 Paris - France
Phone: +33 141 409 700 - Fax: +33 141 409 709 - Email: <secretariat@hsc.fr>
- Page 20 -